Thursday, July 17, 2008

Can There Be 'Wow' in Vista Marketing?

Yesterday's Microsoft marketing bravado is just too funny. So now, 17 months after general availability, Microsoft will promote Windows Vista? Get a life.

The big talk and promises came from Microsoft's Worldwide Partner Conference, in Houston, where Brad Brooks fessed up about Vista marketing mistakes and promised there would be response to Apple's "Get a Mac" ads. They say that confession is good for the corporate soul. I say that it's not good enough.

Microsoft should never have abandoned the original "Wow" Windows Vista marketing campaign. It brought new meaning to the term "marketing blitz." The campaign flashed by before anybody could blink and say, "Wow." Even if Microsoft executives loathed the ads, better to keep them than have nothing. I remain convinced that the Vista marketing campaign could have been very effective. The TV commercials were aspirational, potentially creating positive feelings about the then-mysterious Windows Vista.

Products don't sell themselves. There are good reasons why companies market their stuff. Products must be sold. The best sales pitch is life betterment. Why are people waiting a week in line to buy Apple's iPhone 3G? Because they believe the device will make better their puny little lives. Apple iPhone TV commercials run during most popular primetime programs. The marketing works.

There has been nobody out there saying how good is Windows Vista. But there are plenty of voices, including Apple's "Get a Mac" ads, shouting about how bad is the operating system. It's disgusting that Microsoft showed so little Vista marketing concern for so long. Any ad would be better than none.

Suddenly, there's bravado. Microsoft is making promises about real Vista marketing. Earth to Microsoft, it's going to be too little too late. Windows Vista is the high school outcast. It has got a bad reputation, and people won't easily forget. Marketing damage control is better than nothing, but it could have been avoided. Microsoft should never have given up on "Wow."

Whatever Microsoft does next can't be much worse than nothing. Still, the new marketing campaign, presumably for Windows Vista plus Windows Live, has got to have punch. The marketing must be creative, funny and aspirational—why your life will be better for buying a Windows Vista PC. Microsoft has to make people want Vista.

I grew up in Northern Maine about 16 kilometers from the Canadian border. The local CBC TV station, out of Saint John, New Brunswick, ran these crazy shampoo commercials. The theme: An American would try to smuggle the shampoo into the United States, only to be repeatedly caught by Canadian Customs. The shampoo was only sold in Canada, but was so good Americans would risk going to jail for smuggling out the hair contraband. The ads tapped into feelings about Canadian pride, American disdain and the product's value. You wanted to buy that shampoo.

To repeat: Microsoft marketing has to make people want to buy Windows Vista. The marketing will fail if it's about features or appeals to the intellect. Most purchasing decisions are emotional. Featuring people in ads is one of the most effective ways of generating good feelings about products. After all, people can connect to other human beings—there is common base—and people use the products. Apple's "Get a Mac" ads are effective because of how well they use people as metaphors for conveying typically complicated technological gobbledygook.

This afternoon, I drank some coffee to fire up the synapses, pondering what kind of commercials could be effective. I humbly offer up a couple, starting with response to "Get a Mac" anti-Vista propaganda. Microsoft shouldn't directly attack Apple. Better: Parody the "Get a Mac" ads, making a subtle but important point about Windows PCs. For this one, viral video would be better than commercial broadcast.

Here's what I'd do: The video opens with two guys standing against a white background, just like Apple's commercials. The viewer hears the familiar "Hello, I'm a Mac." "And I'm a PC." Then another guy appears, "And I'm a PC." Another and another and another appears, with popping sounds, each saying, "And I'm a PC." This goes on for about 10 seconds, with hundreds of PC people from different races and cultural attire popping up to overlapping choruses of "And I'm a PC." Then there is silence. The Mac guy looks at the thousands of PC people and mutters, "Wow." Across the screen flashes text: "You can be alone. Or you can have friends." The Windows Vista logo flashes. Video ends.

Everybody knows that there are more Windows PCs than Macs, right? The commercial would play on connotations of safety in numbers, community and fear of being alone. Human beings are social creatures, after all.

Here's another idea, and the last one. I'm not an advertising expert. These concepts are tough for me to think up: The scene opens on a park playground, with a woman facing us; she taps on a notebook resting in her lap. The camera zooms in as her friend walks up pushing a baby carriage. The woman immediately closes the lid, and her friend reacts with surprise. "Jane, what was that for? What are you hiding?" There is short silence, and the woman flips the lid to show the Vista desktop. "It's Windows Vista. I've heard so many bad things, I'm a little embarrassed about using it. But I really like Windows Vista. It's simply amazing." The friend shakes her head and smiles. She reaches into her tote bag, pulls out a laptop and flips the lid. It's Windows Vista. Both women laugh.

There are lots of ways Microsoft could wrap up the commercial; I'm more anxious to blog this post than make suggestions. I can't imagine Microsoft ever airing such a concept, though. But Microsoft needs something this aggressive—that hits hard at the Vista negativity and appeals to people that like the operating system. The commercial could easily feature two teens instead of mothers. Kids understand about being ostracized, as do many parents of middle or high school students.

How will Microsoft really market Windows Vista? We may soon find out.

Monday, July 14, 2008

Microsoft's Extinction-Level Event

If you're a dinosaur, extinction is inevitable.

But dinosaurs aren't replaced by mammals overnight. Evolution is a long process, which is why Microsoft can get away with its convoluted approach to partnering on hosted Web services. And I don't believe Microsoft's partner pitch; snake oil salesmen and pyramid schemers have made it before.

Simply put: Microsoft hosted services will bring some partners to extinction, because to make the big money they'll have to commoditize their own market. Shall I repeat that?

To quickly recap: Today at the Worldwide Partner Conference in Houston, Microsoft announced pricing for its Online Services, which initially will be available in Deskless and Business Productivity suites. The Deskless version costs $3 per employee per month for light versions of Exchange or SharePoint. The full suite, at $15 per employee per month, offers up hosted Communications, Exchange, Office Live and SharePoint products. Microsoft partners that sell the suite get up to 18 percent back the first year and 6 percent back thereafter.

"Once a quarter we send them a check," said Eron Kelly, director of Microsoft Online Services, during a conference call today.

Eron used the example of a partner selling 3,000 seats of Microsoft Online Services, which would have "almost $100,000 in residual fees." By my reckoning, that's $540,000 to Microsoft the first year and $97,200 for the partner—or $24,300 for the first partner payment. That's a helluva lot of upfront incentive for a partner to sell Microsoft hosted services.

But Eron's additional-year partner payback didn't initially add up for me. "By the end of the third year, that would grow to $162,000 if they were able to add those 3,000 seats each year." By my math, the partner would get $32,400 per year or $64,800 at the end of the third year. Near the end of the conference call, I asked Eron to explain his math. He's assuming that the partner would sell an additional 3,000 seats, not keep them as I assumed he meant.

Let me be clear: I know Microsoft isn't selling some kind of pyramid scheme, but it sure feels like it. The only way to sustain the revenue stream is to sell more seats in subsequent years. Here's how the math works out: In year two, the partner would make $129,600 by selling 3,000 more seats. In the third year, that take would be the aforementioned $162,000. In the fourth year, again adding 3,000 seats, the incentive would be $194,400. Half that amount, $97,200, would be equivalent to the partner's take from the first year incentive.

Partners must continue selling more hosted services seats to sustain Microsoft's payback. From Microsoft's perspective, it has got to be a sensible model. Partners make more by selling more. It's Partnering 101. But the process also cannibalizes the partners' market, by commoditizing server software that they would otherwise sell or service.

Microsoft Is the Landlord
Eron put forth some lamebrain perspective about how much partners would make selling additional services, such as Active Directory and Exchange e-mail integration, to support Microsoft Online Services. D`oh, these are short-term, not long-term services. There is a point where the work is done, because the customer has moved out of the owned property into a rental unit.

Microsoft is the new landlord, when the moving is done. The partner then gets paid by property owner Microsoft rather than by the enterprise business owner. Microsoft pays less over time, unless the partner moves more of its customers to rental units. By providing direct services under contract to businesses that own their own property, so to speak, the partner can collect ongoing services, maintenance and help desk fees.

I haven't done the hard math on this yet, but let's try a hypothetical scenario. Partner Bill has 12,000 seats, same number which in my aforementioned example he would have converted to hosted services over four years. Hypothetically, Bill collects a mere 10 bucks per seat for providing comprehensive site maintenance, including testing, deployment and management services. That's $120,000 a month in service fees, or $1.4 million a year. What if Bill made just $3 per seat per month, same as Microsoft charges for its Deskless suite? That's $36,000 a month, or $432,000 in one year. Bill doesn't need to aggressively sell 3,000 more seats each year, but simply organically grow his business and properly service existing customers to maintain them.

The example oversimplifies, because the partner assumes additional costs that would reduce margin of profits. For Online Services, Microsoft would assume more of the costs of doing business, but by no means all. Example: Sales and marketing. In the ownership example, the partner maintains customers and steadier revenue stream. For Microsoft rentals, the partner turns over customers to Microsoft, reducing the long-term pool of customers, commoditizing server software services and requiring further commoditization to continue generating revenue.

For partners looking to expand their businesses, Microsoft has given them incentive to get new customers and for a handsome first-year cut of the proceeds. But the gains, whether from hosting sales or partner-provided migration services, are short term. First benefit goes to Microsoft, which fosters commoditization to its benefit; better that Microsoft gets paid for hosted services than Google, Salesforce.com or other Web 2.0 platform companies.

Microsoft doesn't want to be the dinosaur, which is why the model now embraces hosted services. But Microsoft's partner approach to hosted services is sure to ensure that many partners will remain dinosaur's bound for extinction. Perhaps this year's Worldwide Partner Conference should be called Microsoft's "Extinction-Level Event."


Sunday, July 13, 2008

Microsoft's Suite Response to Google, Partners

As the saying goes, Microsoft will rob Peter to pay Paul.

Today, at its Worldwide Partner Conference, Microsoft announced pricing and partner compensation for its suite of Online Services. The venue is somewhat surprising, because Microsoft-hosted services directly compete with similar offerings from its partners. Microsoft's solution: Cut in partners on the action.

In a Google world of free services supported by advertising, Microsoft's competitive response options are limited. Microsoft doesn't have a successful enough search and advertising platform to compete with Google in free services such as Docs; there is too much risk of hurting sales of desktop and server products such as Exchange Server and Office; and Microsoft is dependent on a large network of partners to sell its wares. There are few giveaway options.

Microsoft's compromise is to offer services cheap, while compensating partners. It's a risky move, because channel conflict is inevitable. Microsoft can coat this bitter pill in sugar, but the taste lingers: The company is directly competing with its partners.

The company's first Online Service is called the Deskless Worker suite. Ala carte offerings for "light" online versions of Exchange or SharePoint cost $3 per employee per month. The whole Business Productivity Online Suite—hosted Communications, Exchange, Live Meeting and SharePoint—is $15 per employee per month. The math looks good for Microsoft and its customers. A company with 50 employees would pay $750 a month or $27,000 over three years, which is a typical time period for Microsoft volume-licensing contract with Software Assurance.

My initial response to the pricing, without doing a hard volume-licensing comparison, is positive. But Microsoft still charges quite a bit more than does Google for Apps, which are $50 per user per year. Microsoft's suite is $180 per user per year, assuming there are no hidden discounts or other devil-in-the-details considerations.

Microsoft gets recurring revenue from real subscriptions, not just volume-licensing commitments. Customers get hosted services from Microsoft that are in some ways better than packaged software. Microsoft takes on the administrative and technical burdens, which conceptually would reduce staffing and other IT Management costs. You can buy a home, or you can rent. If you rent, the landlord assumes responsibility for maintenance, upkeep and taxes. Microsoft is going into the IT landlord business.

But Microsoft has a problem: Its partners, whom Microsoft relies on to sell and service its products. The company has no large, dedicated sales force. Microsoft can't afford to piss off its partners. Microsoft Online Services compete with partners, whether they're selling or servicing on-premise software or selling their own hosted services using Microsoft partners.

Microsoft is trying to alleviate partner conflict by cutting them in on the action. Partners selling Productivity or Deskless suites will get 12 percent of the first-year contract, plus 6 percent of subscription fees. So, first-year bang is 18 percent. The aforementioned 50-seat example that could work out to $1,620 for the first year. I say could, because the devil is in the details with respect for what Microsoft accounts for when. Regardless, that's recurring revenue for the partner. In this scenario, $540 per year ($45 a month) from the subscription's second year.

Is that compensation model enough to alleviate channel conflict? Ideally, customers would still require something on the desktop, meaning Office and Windows. So there is real software that partners could sell and service. But the big money is on the server, and Microsoft would take away from some partners recurring service and maintenance fees. The hosted service kickback fees wouldn't make up for them, not for truly successful partners. Channel conflict is inevitable.

Should Microsoft be blamed for competing with its partners? Yes and no. The "yes" is Microsoft's over-dependence on the partner model. This isn't the first time Microsoft had to kick back money to partners, simply to avoid competing—or just the appearance of competing—with them. Best example: volume licensing, which technically should be a direct relationship with customers, but Microsoft cuts in partners. It's hush money. Don't complain. Be happy.

The "no" acknowledges a changing marketplace. Competition from Google and other Web 2.0 platform companies is real. There has to come a point where, say, Google's online suite, including Calendar, Docs and Gmail, is good enough for many businesses to stop buying Office. Increasing mobility—the need for informational access anytime, anywhere and on anything—creates a clear future for hosted software, whether done by the enterprise, Microsoft or one of its partners—or coming from competing, ad-supported or lower-cost products. Change is inevitable, too.

These changes affect the partner model by commoditizing some of the products and services they offer today. From that perspective, Microsoft is being generous to its partners. Microsoft is adapting its business to a changing computational marketplace, and it's cutting in partners on a piece of the action. It's adapt or die. If you're a dinosaur, extinction is inevitable.

Saturday, July 12, 2008

Microsoft Makes November 'Essential'

What is it with Microsoft and the second and third weeks of November?

Today, the company announced that Small Business Server 2008 and Essential Business Server 2008 would launch on Nov. 12. That's a popular week for Microsoft products. Some November blasts from the past:

  • Zune 2, Nov. 12, 2007
  • Office 2007 and Windows Vista, Nov. 30, 2006
  • Zune, Nov. 13, 2006
  • Xbox 360, Nov. 22, 2005
  • Halo 2, Nov. 9, 2004
  • Tablet PC 2004, Nov. 17, 2003
  • Xbox Live, Nov. 15, 2002
  • Xbox, Nov. 15, 2001

Is it like tradition for Microsoft to have big November product launches? The consumer products make sense for the holidays and then there was Comdex for business stuff. But the trade show is long gone. So, the reason to launch new server software is November for small and medium businesses that probably won't be looking to deploy over the holidays. "Merry Christmas, honey. It's Small Business Server 2008!"

Microsoft announced product pricing in June, so the products are moving ahead, but ever so slowly. Right now, release to manufacturing is tracking late August to early September. SQL Server 2008's late delivery is one major reason for the slow advance. And Microsoft has set dates whether or not SQL Server 2008 will be ready.

"We are going to be shipping SQL 2005 and SQL 2008 on our media in the box," Steven VanRoekel, Microsoft's senior director of the Windows Server Solutions group, told me last week. Microsoft is providing both versions for customers that might want the 2005 edition and coverage for still uncertain SQL Server 2008 availability.

Meanwhile, Microsoft isn't thumb twiddling until November. The company is readying the channel for SBS and EBS, such as delivering new SDKs and Solutions Pathway, a tool for calculating migration discounts from other Microsoft software (25 to 35 percent). Microsoft also will offer up to $200 rebates to partners whose customers acquire Software Assurance on new SBS 2003 R2 installations.

Microsoft will disclose more about the SBS and EBS partner programs and incentives, starting tomorrow, July 8, at the Worldwide Partner Conference.

"We're going to have a huge presence at the partner conference," VanRoekel said. "We'll have a larger booth than Windows and Windows Live. You're going to see us there loud and proud."

While "loud" applies to both products, EBS is a new category and one targeting a segment that has long been neglected, at least by Microsoft. EBS will be louder.

"One of the problems that we had in the midmarket is they've [partners] never had something they could really offer," VanRoekel acknowledged. EBS is Microsoft's server software entry into this segment. "There's a great consolidation story," he said. "The typical midmarket org uses seven to nine servers compared to EBS' three to four servers."

Microsoft wants to bring cultural change to midmarket IT managers. Steven said "the lifestyle midmarket IT lives" is "reactionary." EBS' goal: to make proactive management the lifestyle.


Friday, July 11, 2008

Yahoo, What Icahn Do to You

Microsoft has made clear its intentions: to work with billionaire Carl Icahn for the end of Yahoo. So, this is Plan B: Snatch Yahoo search in a boardroom coup.

In an official statement issued today, Microsoft revealed that "in the past week we have had the opportunity to discuss with Carl Icahn the prospects for a possible agreement between Microsoft and Yahoo." Presumably that agreement would lead to Microsoft acquiring Yahoo's core search capabilities, which, as I've said, would lobotomize the media company.

The billionaire board buster bolsters his own position in a separate letter:

"During the past week I have spoken frequently with Steve Ballmer, CEO of Microsoft. Several of our conversations have lasted as long as an hour. Also, a few of our discussions have taken place while other top executives, such as Kevin Johnson, participated. Our talks centered on the industry in general but, more importantly, on how Yahoo and Microsoft can do a transaction together."

The statements clearly expose Microsoft's back-room corporate maneuverings. CEO Steve Ballmer and Co. aren't so squeaky clean after all. Microsoft's decision not to engage Yahoo in a proxy fight seemed sensible at the time—Microsoft withdrew its bid and decided to fight no longer. From Steve's May 3 Yahoo bid withdrawal letter:

"After giving this week's conversations further thought, it is clear to me that it is not sensible for Microsoft to take our offer directly to your shareholders. This approach would necessarily involve a protracted proxy contest and eventually an exchange offer. Our discussions with you have led us to conclude that, in the interim, you would take steps that would make Yahoo undesirable as an acquisition for Microsoft."

But that's not exactly true. Carl Icahn already was publicly hanging around, ready to take some action. Microsoft executives had to know this, and they may even have been contacted by the billionaire board buster. Microsoft didn't need to engage in a nasty proxy fight, because Carl was ready to do it again, as he had done with other companies.

Now the two sides are talking and not just to each other. Today's Microsoft letter was clearly for the eyes of Yahoo shareholders, whose votes Carl Icahn needs for orchestrating a proxy-fight-driven boardroom coup. From Microsoft's letter released today:

"Despite working since Jan. 31 of this year, as well as in the early part of last year, we have never been able to reach an agreement in a timely way on acceptable terms with the current management and Board of Directors at Yahoo. We have concluded that we cannot reach an agreement with them. We confirm, however, that after the shareholder election Microsoft would be interested in discussing with a new board a major transaction with Yahoo, such as either a transaction to purchase the 'Search' function with large financial guarantees or, in the alternative, purchasing the whole company."

If Yahoo shareholders want a deal with Microsoft, it has got to be with a new board. That's going to be a long-term losing deal for Yahoo shareholders, methinks. Their best return would come from a full Microsoft acquisition, something that would be bad for Microsoft. Obtaining Yahoo search would be good for Microsoft but be bad for Yahoo in the long term. Search is the core around which everything else revolves. Take away search and Yahoo spins apart, painfully, over several years.

I find this just laughable, from Microsoft's letter:

"As Mr. Icahn notes in his statement today, it would be premature to discuss at this time important details such as the price or other terms of a possible transaction. We respect the right of Yahoo's shareholders to determine the destiny of their company, and we do not intend to engage in ongoing commentary on these issues in advance of Yahoo's shareholder meeting."

"Respect the right" to "determine the destiny?" Oh, please! Microsoft has been trying to seize hold of Yahoo's destiny since making the unsolicited offer. And today's letter is all about influencing the destiny "in advance of Yahoo's shareholder meeting."

More from Microsoft's letter:

"As we explained on June 12 when Yahoo announced an agreement with Google, we believe that our proposed search acquisition and partnership would have delivered superior value to Yahoo's shareholders and the marketplace as a whole. We have not changed our position, even as we continue to move forward with our own online search and advertising offerings. We therefore welcome interest by Mr. Icahn in pursuing this and other discussions.
"While of course there can be no assurance of a future transaction, we will be prepared to enter into discussions immediately after Yahoo's shareholder meeting if a new board is elected."

Interpretation: Microsoft will hold no more discussions with Yahoo's current board of directors; Microsoft will engage Carl Icahn discussions; and a deal, if any, will only happen with a new board. How's that for trying to influence the vote?

In a shareholder letter responding to Microsoft and Carl Icahn, Yahoo asserted willingness to re-engage Microsoft discussions, and rightly identified what's really going on here.

"Mr. Ballmer and Mr. Icahn have teamed up in an apparent effort to force Yahoo into selling to Microsoft its Search business at a price to be determined in a future 'negotiation' between Mr. Icahn's directors and Microsoft's management. We feel very strongly that this would not lead to an outcome that would be in the best interests of Yahoo's stockholders."

Right, right. Microsoft no longer wants to buy Yahoo, just the search business. Yahoo's board recognizes that such a deal would effectively destroy the company. So Microsoft and Carl Icahn have engaged on an alternative plan, which would be quite good for the software giant. Microsoft would get the best asset from Yahoo, table the Google-Yahoo search deal and send teetering Yahoo as a competitor.


Thursday, July 10, 2008

Yahoo's Response to Carl Icahn

In a shareholder letter, Yahoo affirmed willingness to engage Microsoft in discussions. Text follows.

Yahoo's Board of Directors continues to stand ready to enter into negotiations with Microsoft Corporation for an acquisition of Yahoo. Indeed, as recently as June, Yahoo's independent directors and management approached Steve Ballmer about just such a transaction, only to be told that Microsoft was no longer interested even in the price range which they had previously proposed. Now Mr. Ballmer and Mr. Icahn have teamed up in an apparent effort to force Yahoo into selling to Microsoft its Search business at a price to be determined in a future "negotiation" between Mr. Icahn's directors and Microsoft's management. We feel very strongly that this would not lead to an outcome that would be in the best interests of Yahoo's stockholders. If Microsoft and Mr. Ballmer really want to purchase Yahoo, we again invite them to make a proposal immediately. And if Mr. Icahn has an actual plan for Yahoo beyond hoping that Microsoft might actually consummate a deal which they have repeatedly walked away from, we would be very interested in hearing it.

Wednesday, July 9, 2008

Microsoft's Letter Supporting Carl Icahn

Today, Microsoft issued a Yahoo shareholder influencing letter supporting billionaire board buster Carl Icahn's hostile proxy fight. Text follows.

In the past week we have had the opportunity to discuss with Carl Icahn the prospects for a possible agreement between Microsoft and Yahoo.
Despite working since Jan. 31 of this year, as well as in the early part of last year, we have never been able to reach an agreement in a timely way on acceptable terms with the current management and Board of Directors at Yahoo. We have concluded that we cannot reach an agreement with them. We confirm, however, that after the shareholder election Microsoft would be interested in discussing with a new board a major transaction with Yahoo, such as either a transaction to purchase the "Search" function with large financial guarantees or, in the alternative, purchasing the whole company.
As Mr. Icahn notes in his statement today, it would be premature to discuss at this time important details such as the price or other terms of a possible transaction. We respect the right of Yahoo's shareholders to determine the destiny of their company, and we do not intend to engage in ongoing commentary on these issues in advance of Yahoo's shareholder meeting.
As we explained on June 12 when Yahoo announced an agreement with Google, we believe that our proposed search acquisition and partnership would have delivered superior value to Yahoo's shareholders and the marketplace as a whole. We have not changed our position, even as we continue to move forward with our own online search and advertising offerings. We therefore welcome interest by Mr. Icahn in pursuing this and other discussions.
While of course there can be no assurance of a future transaction, we will be prepared to enter into discussions immediately after Yahoo's shareholder meeting if a new board is elected.

Tuesday, July 8, 2008

Carl Icahn's Letter

Today, billionaire board buster Carl Icahn issued a letter to Yahoo shareholders asking them to oust the board with the promise of a possible new deal with Microsoft. Text follows.

Dear Yahoo Shareholders:
During the past week I have spoken frequently with Steve Ballmer, CEO of Microsoft. Several of our conversations have lasted as long as an hour. Also, a few of our discussions have taken place while other top executives, such as Kevin Johnson, participated. Our talks centered on the industry in general but, more importantly, on how Yahoo and Microsoft can do a transaction together. Steve made it abundantly clear that, due to his experiences with Yahoo during the past several months, he cannot negotiate any transaction with the current board. His logic is simple. If and when a transaction was consummated, Microsoft would be guaranteeing a great deal of capital at closing. However, a transaction could take at least nine months and perhaps longer to obtain regulatory clearance in the U.S., Europe and elsewhere. During that period, if the current board and management team of Yahoo mismanage the company (and their recent track record is far from reassuring), Microsoft would be putting its money at risk and a great deal could be lost.
For example, in a transaction to purchase the whole company, a very large amount of capital would be due at closing. Even in an 'alternate' transaction, where just the "Search" assets were purchased, large guarantees would have to be made and, again, large sums could be lost if the company was mismanaged. Microsoft perceives this risk may be quite high with the current board and management in place. However, Steve made it clear to me that if a new board were elected, he would be interested in discussing a major transaction with Yahoo, such as either a transaction to purchase the "Search" function with large financial guarantees or, in the alternative, purchasing the whole company. He stated that Microsoft would be willing to enter into discussion immediately if the new board that has been nominated were elected. While there can be no assurance of a future transaction, as many of you know, I have negotiated successfully a large number of transactions over the past years. If and when elected, I strongly believe that in very short order the new board would, subject to its fiduciary duties, be presenting to shareholders either a purchase offer for the whole company or a very attractive offer to purchase "Search" with large guarantees. I hope to continue to be speaking to Steve over the next few weeks; however, since I do not as yet represent the Yahoo board, both Steve and I do not wish to get into details over price, or even which of these transactions makes the most sense.
Much has been said about how badly the Yahoo board has 'botched up' negotiations with Microsoft over the past months. There is no need to keep pointing out the mistakes I believe Yahoo made by not immediately taking a $33 offer made by Microsoft. But one thing is clear—Jerry Yang and the current board of Yahoo will not be able to 'botch up' a negotiation with Microsoft again, simply because they will not have the opportunity.
Our company is now moving toward a precipice. It is currently losing market share in its "Search" function; our current Board has failed to bring in a talented and experienced CEO to replace Jerry Yang and return Jerry to his role as Chief Yahoo, and currently it is witnessing a meaningful exodus of talent. It is no secret that Google (which hired a great operator as CEO) continues to dramatically outperform Yahoo. According to publicly available information, Google's income from operations grew 59 percent per year over the last two years while Yahoo's shrank 21 percent per year. However, none of the above has caused the Yahoo board to hesitate in paying themselves $10,000 per week. IT IS TIME FOR A CHANGE.
If elected, I have little doubt that the new board, subject to its fiduciary duties, will do what the current board will not do, i.e.,
  • Immediately start negotiation with Microsoft to sell the whole company or, in the alternative, sell "Search" with large guarantees.
  • Move expeditiously to replace Jerry Yang with a new CEO with operating experience.

Monday, July 7, 2008

Microsoft Partners Get Their Due, But Do You?

Microsoft's annual Worldwide Partner Conference kicks off this week and it's going to be, big, Big, BIG.

During the event, Microsoft typically shows its partners love, and this year will only differ in the amount of love. Microsoft could and perhaps should call 2008 the "Year of the Partner." At no other time in its history has Microsoft offered partners more reasons to get exited or more reasons to worry (more on the worrisome stuff in a few paragraphs).

Microsoft has more products in the market requiring a partner's touch than any other year in the company's history. The best for partners: How Microsoft is packaging disparate products as enterprise solutions in categories like business intelligence or unified communications that require hefty testing, deployment and ongoing maintenance services. Better still, many Microsoft products are more complicated than ever, particularly when interacting with the company's other software.

Take Office 2007 and its new user interface, which necessitates extra training or help desk support; or the new server-function SKUs, which nearly require a mathematics degree to understand the pricing structure and benefits. Then there's Windows Vista, where hefty system requirements and resistance to custom applications mean lots of testing and integration work for somebody. Windows Vista is sure to keep many Microsoft partners fat and sassy even in lean economic times.

SharePoint Server 2007 is Microsoft's grab bag solution for collaboration, content management and blogging. Those team sites multiply faster than rabbits, and they're even tougher to manage. Microsoft marketing is pushing SharePoint harder than ever, plus there's a lot of cross-product integration with the server software.

Best yet: It's raining server software. Hyper-V, SQL Server 2008 and Windows Server 2008 are the starters. Plus, there's a new line of "Essential" business server software. Somebody is going to have to integrate this stuff. Can you say "Microsoft partners?"

But, using a highly overused Microsoft term, the "goodness" doesn't stop there. Microsoft is going into the hosted server software business, where it will compete with some partners. But not to worry, partners. The choices—partner hosted, self hosted or Microsoft hosted—will be confusing enough for many enterprises, so there will be plenty of consulting and integration services for somebody.

While my tone is a wee bit facetious, the partner opportunities are real and Microsoft has been quietly assembling supporting marketing and sales programs for them. Some of that valuable disclosure comes in the form of interoperability information that's sure to generate business for savvy partners looking to better piece together Microsoft products or join them with third-party products.

Who Really Pays?
My question for Microsoft: What do "real" customers pay extra for the privilege of all that partner assistance? I chuckle at nearly every Microsoft press release that touts enterprise benefits from the latest products or solutions that are simpler to use. Really? Simpler for whom? What I see is increasing complexity, everywhere. There are more Microsoft widgets to assemble together, more widgets requiring other ones to work and more complicated licensing SKUs for the widgets.

Microsoft doesn't have a big, dedicated sales force. The company relies heavily on partners to sell, as well as deploy and service its software. Microsoft's business model is intricately entwined with middle-men—partners—who make lots of money from complexity. Sure, other high-tech companies—like HP, IBM, Oracle or Sun—thrive on services. But, I believe, Microsoft's dependence on its third-party sales channel is a disincentive trait, and this leads to its enterprise software being more complex than needed. It's a symbiotic Microsoft-partner relationship where complexity is the common base.

So, I come to the important question: Who is Microsoft's real first customer? I say, it's the partners long before the enterprises actually paying for and using the software. Partners get their due—and there's plenty coming in 2008 and 2009—but do enterprises? I wonder how much better Microsoft software could be if it were engineered for enterprises as the first customer.

I suppose that some Microsoft product managers will contend that the software user, whether consumer or business, is the first customer. My response: Then why is there so much more benefit to the people selling or integrating the software? And why is there still so much complexity—and by my observance, more of it?

No question: It's a great time to be a Microsoft partner. Exception: This week's punishing heat. Why would any company hold a conference in Houston in July? The daily high temperature is expected to be about 90 degrees Fahrenheit and balmy, with humidity around 75 percent every day.

Sunday, July 6, 2008

Microhoo: Breaking Up Is Hard to Do

Rumors that Microsoft wants to break up Yahoo make sense to me. Steveo won't let go.

Today, the Wall Street Journal reported that Microsoft has sought out at least News Corp. and Time Warner as partners for picking away pieces of Yahoo—break it up. Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer apparently still wants Yahoo's search business. If Yahoo won't willingly give it up, Microsoft will just take it.

Such a tactic isn't the least bit far-fetched. Yahoo's board is choking on the company's free-falling stock price, and billionaire Carl Icahn is waging a proxy fight to oust at least some board members. Meanwhile, Yahoo talent is leaping into the icy waters of job uncertainty rather than stay on the listing ship.

Yeah, Yahoo could be picked apart, with Microsoft getting the choice meat—search. I'm mixing metaphors, but there are so many sophomoric, metaphoric angles to this plot, I simply can't contain my enthusiasm. The whole "breaking up" concept is loaded with fun, sophomoric interpretations:

  • The jilted lover syndrome, where Microsoft courted Yahoo, which rebuffed its advances. Now, it's time for some sweet revenge; if I can't have you nobody can. I'll destroy you. I'm gonna break you up, baby.
  • "Hey hey, you you, I want to be your girlfriend." Yahoo fell into Google's loving arms. That's a relationship Microsoft can't stand not to break up.
  • What's good enough for you isn't good enough for me. Microsoft fought the Justice Department over 2000 sanctions that demanded the company breakup. Microsoft wouldn't split into separate companies but it has no qualms about breaking up Yahoo. Oh, the irony is thick.

The Journal positioned the talks with News Corp. and Time Warner as "preliminary and unlikely to result in a deal with Yahoo." Maybe, but the talks themselves are the point. Microsoft hasn't given up on getting something from Yahoo. The goal is no longer is the whole Yahoo but the piece that matters most to Microsoft—search.

I want to editorialize that Journal statement: "Unlikely to result in a deal with Yahoo" now. If Carl seizes control of Yahoo's board, there may be a sudden willingness for any deal and more interest from third parties to join in the pickings.

What I want to know: Why isn't Microsoft talking to Amazon.com? I stand by my long-ago stated opinion that an Amazon-Yahoo match-up looks really good. It could be a whole lot better if Amazon didn't have to assume all that search mucky muck; just outsource elsewhere.

But Amazoo could create other problems Microsoft wouldn't want to deal with later. Microsoft is already fixing to compete with Amazon's hosted data center services, which Yahoo could greatly extend. Amazoo could also tie many existing Yahoo services, such as Messenger, Shopping or even Flickr, to its retail engine.

Whomever the partners, if any, Microsoft isn't done trying to wrestle search from Yahoo. If that means a Yahoo corpse to get search, certainly. The break up plan adds more meaning to the saying, "Over my dead body."


Saturday, July 5, 2008

Microsoft 'Equipts' Consumers

Why would anyone pay $150 for Office 2007 Home and Student when they could get it and more for less than half the price?

That's the question Microsoft is hoping some consumers will ask about Equipt, the new subscription offering formerly code-named Albany. The question Microsoft might not want these same people to ask: Why spend 70 bucks when Google Docs is free?

This morning, Microsoft announced that the subscription product would be available through 700 Circuit City stores on July 15 for a 12-month subscription fee of $69.95. Equipt comes with the aforementioned Office version, Windows Live OneCare, Mail, Messenger and Photo Gallery. The subscription service also connects to Office Live Workspace for document sharing and collaboration. Equipt can be activated on up to three PCs, which is consistent with current Office Home and Student and OneCare licensing.

I expect plenty of commentators to view the announcement as a Microsoft versus Google thing. There's a little of that maybe, but I see Equipt more as Microsoft advancing further into the consumer subscription market and more closely aligning desktop and Web services. Revealing: Microsoft is leveraging a very different distribution channel than Google (more on that in a few paragraphs).

The question Bryson Gordon, Office group product manager asks: "How can we take rich client experiences we have today and how can we extend them into the cloud?"

That's exactly the thinking to expect from a Microsoft executive—how to maintain and extend the relevancy of desktop software to Web services. More importantly: How to best provide consumers with the newest software, while collecting ongoing subscription fees from them. "This is a subscription service, and one of the things we're committed to is making things better over time," Bryson said. "With Equipt everything is up to date." That includes the newest Office version.

Microsoft also sees Equipt as an anti-piracy effort. "The majority of the sales of Equipt are going to be coming from people that have an old copy of Office or received a copy from Bob up the street," Bryson said.

Equipt risks more to Microsoft than it offers a competitive advantage against Google's Web-based productivity suite. The subscription software/service could pull sales from à la carte OneCare and full-version Office Home and Student, which accounts for the majority of Office retail sales, according to the NPD Group.

"Yeah, there probably is going to be some cannibalization," Bryson conceded. But Microsoft research shows cannibalization will be low, he emphasized. Maybe, but I wonder about Office Standard. It's not like Microsoft is carding people to see where they'll be using the software. For many small businesses, particularly those already using Hotmail, Equipt may be all the Office equipment they need.

That's good segue for Microsoft's novel, early distribution channel for Equipt. "To reach the right kind of customer, we need a certain kind of sales motion," Bryson said. "With Equipt it's not just a process of put the product on the shelf, or put the product on the Web. Retail is the right place for us to start."

But not just every retail store. At launch, Equipt will only be "available in 700 stores across Circuit City." Bryson said. Microsoft has chosen a single distribution channel. Bryson said Microsoft picked Circuit City because the retailer was ready to engage customers in a "kind of a high-touch scenario. Equipt is better sold than bought."

Really? What's so high touch about Office? Everything. Most products are sold, not bought. Marketing matters—it's everything. Equipt is different and potentially confusing to consumers because it changes the model: no perpetual license, 12-month recurring fees and blended desktop and Web-based products. Equipt should be sold, as should many, many other Microsoft products that get shelf space and little more.

"We were looking to limit the distribution of this...to ensure the sales process was in place," Bryson said.

The choice of a single retailer is smart. Microsoft partners better than any other company on the planet. But to a fault. Microsoft deals too evenly with too many partners. Some partners do better than others; they should be given preferential treatment. I commend Microsoft for singling out Circuit City.

Bryson made it absolutely clear that Equipt will be available through other channels, and perhaps, even shortly from other retailers. Circuit City distribution puts other retail partners on notice: The rules are changing. Microsoft needs to do a whole lot more of picking favorites even if it pisses off some partners. A big Windows Vista plus Windows Live marketing blitz is soon coming. If I were Microsoft, only the best and most cooperative retailers would get the in-store displays, co-marketing dollars and Sunday circular ad support. It's long past the time when Microsoft played favorites.

Something else before closing: The name works. Equipt evokes good connotations of having the right equipment. Microsoft's nomenclature continues to slowly improve. That said, the packaging and subbranding, which I didn't see until today, really don't work. Rather than giving the new product its own, clear-brand identity, Microsoft put box shots of Office Home and Student and Windows Live OneCare on the Equipt box. Mixing brands like this might seem like a good idea by leveraging existing products. I don't agree. Like other, newer Microsoft products with better nomenclature—Expression Studio, Zune or Surface, among others—Equipt should have a distinct brand and logo. Hopefully, the in-store marketing materials will be better.


Friday, July 4, 2008

Microsoft Joins the Powerset

The rumors were true, but not punditry about Powerset being Microsoft's search Plan B.

There has been talk about a Plan B ever since Microsoft withdrew its unsolicited offer for Yahoo about two months ago. Powerset is a good buy for Microsoft, but by no means Plan B for catching Google. That said, it's a helluva acquisition with long-term promise because of the Powerset team.

Microsoft officially announced acquisition of Powerset today. I kind of laughed reading the blog post, thinking back to an e-mail I got from Powerset last week about its new search product for Wikipedia and why it would be great for iPhone. Right, like I'll be getting any more iPhone-loving e-mail from Powerset now that Microsoft has come a calling.

Powerset is an important acquisition for Microsoft because it represents the Holy Grail of search long touted by CEO Steve Ballmer and Live Search executives: Natural language search. For years, Microsoft execs have taken the position that search is still in its infancy, even while Google gobbled up search share—now over 60 percent, according to ComScore. The theory: Keywords suck. People want to ask questions.

There's something to that asking questions stuff being a more natural way of looking for information. Keyword search is more than a means to an end, it's how Google makes money—surely Microsoft would like to tweak the business model as much as improve searches. (I'm being a wee bit facetious, as Powerset displays Google search keywords with its results; surely that will be one of the first changes Microsoft makes. Can you say Live Search keywords?)

Powerset is a hot startup, focusing on natural language search and with the new Wikipedia search feature little more than a month in market. As a Powertest test, I typed: "What are the five continents?" It's kind of a trick questions. Where I grew up, teachers taught about seven continents, but schools in some other countries use a smaller number. I got a surprising answer and learned something I should have known (shame on me): That the Olympic rings stand for the five inhabited continents. Way to go Powerset and Wikipedia.

Powerset puts the Wikipedia information in its own page with the aforementioned contextual ad keywords. There's definitely a business model here.

In announcing the acquisition, Satya Nadella, Microsoft's senior veep for Search, Portal, and Advertising, blogged:

"Problems exist because search engines today primarily match words in a search to words on a Web page. We can solve these problems by working to understand the intent behind each search and the concepts and meaning embedded in a Web page. Doing so, we can innovate in the quality of the search results, in the flexibility with which searchers can phrase their queries, and in the search user experience. We will use knowledge extracted from Web pages to improve the result descriptions and provide new tools to help customers search better."

Satya may be right, but this is an old song. Microsoft has sung so often about natural search, without reaching crescendo. Google may be unbeatable by the time there is a competitive solution from Microsoft. I look at Powerset as Microsoft's last chance to get natural search right, if it's not already too late. Windows long ago showed that better isn't necessary to be market leader, just good enough. Are keywords good enough? Maybe, if most everyone uses Google from their PCs (But Google isn't everywhere, as I will explain in the last paragraph of this post).

"Powerset will join our core Search Relevance team, remaining intact in San Francisco," Satya wrote. "More importantly, Powerset brings to Live Search a set of talented engineers and computational linguists in downtown San Francisco. This is a great team with a wide range of experience from other search engines and research organizations like PARC (formerly Xerox PARC)."

Remember Xerox PARC and the engineers who really developed the graphical user interface and mouse? PARC also is credited with WYSIWYG editing and the laser printer, among other inventions. So there is a certain esteem attached to any company remotely affiliated with PARC.

Microsoft picks up an impressive team of technologists with Powerset—perhaps the acquisition's most valuable asset:

  • Barney Pell, co-founder and CTO, worked for NASA and has a doctorate from Cambridge
  • Lorenzo Thione, co-founder and director of natural language technologies, is an expert in computational linguistics
  • Scott Prevost, general manger, has expertise in voice and facial natural user interfaces
  • Ron Kaplan, chief science officer, was chief scientist for PARC spin-off Microlytics and is another expert with natural language technologies
  • Chad Walters, search architect, is Yahoo's former Websearch architect
  • Tim Converse, director of ranking and metrics, is another former Yahoo, leading the webspam algorithms team there.

The list isn't exclusive, just the people identified by Satya's blog post. They're an impressive collection of natural user interface experts and visionaries who are coming to a company that desperately needs to rediscover its technical heritage and leadership.

Most importantly, they have expertise in areas of search that could be applied in areas where Google hasn't yet conquered. Maybe that's the endgame Microsoft can win. The mobile phone is the next big search platform, the one that will by comparison dwarf PCs. There's a reason why last week I got a Powerset PR pitch about iPhone.

Who will really want to type in keywords on a cell phone? That's going to be no way to search. Speak search? Oh, yeah. Natural language search makes a helluva lot of sense on cell phones. And Microsoft just added a hell of a crew to its Live Search core Search Relevance team.

Thursday, July 3, 2008

Microsoft Pumps Your Gas

I've heard Windows Vista called a gas guzzler, which pumps a little irony into Microsoft's newest contest.

Today, Microsoft Small Business formerly announced a marketing campaign/contest to give away 5,000 gallons of gasoline. With gas prices near five bucks in some places (like Southern California), Microsoft is encouraging businesses to stay at work and collaborate or conference online.

I initially resisted blogging the gas giveaway, which I read about early this morning in a post on the Microsoft SMB Community blog. Eric Ligman, senior manager for Microsoft Small Business Community Engagement, wrote:

"We want to make sure small businesses have the information they need to make smart decisions about cutting costs and becoming more efficient. As a first step in this effort, we are offering 5 money-saving ideas and the opportunity to win 5,000 gallons of gas at BumptheSlump.com. So, check it out, enter to win and remember to pass along the good news. Your customers will definitely love you for pointing them to the gas giveaway and may even want to tap into your small business technical expertise about some of the money-saving ideas."

Ad agency Bradley and Montgomery created the advertising campaign, which apparently is just a first effort. Coming in July: A SMB social networking site, according to PR e-mail sent this afternoon. What? Facebook or Windows Live Spaces aren't social networking enough?

Oh, I almost forgot: The contest can be found at bumptheslump.com. I totally barfed my coffee when seeing link "Stack the deck. Send this to all your coworkers." Yeah, right. Like I want to spam everybody.

By the way, the contest's fine print indicates it's not really gas but "Shell prepaid gas cards." Also: "Open only to small businesses legally domiciled in the 50 United States (includes D of C) that have between 2 and 100 employees. Game ends July 18, 2008."

What I don't get: The rules say the contest started on June 19. OK, so why is Microsoft publicizing this thing today? I love this: The gift cards are $250 each, for a 5,000 gallon total with an "approximate Retail Value (ARV) US $20,350.00 based on AAA US national average of $4.07." Say, what? Average gas price here in San Diego today is $4.59. But Microsoft's not getting off easy. U.S. government stats put the national gas price average at $4.09 today.

As for gas guzzling Vista, I referred to its heftier hardware requirements as compared to Windows XP.

Wednesday, July 2, 2008

Microsoft Reaches Interoperability 1.0

Today, Microsoft announced the release of more interoperability information, including legacy, Office binary file formats.

The updated protocol information is available here, on the MSDN (Microsoft Developer Network).

Microsoft also released final protocol information for 2007 versions of Exchange Server, Office 2007 and SharePoint Server. The information moves "from preliminary to 1.0 stage," Craig Shank, Microsoft's general manager of Interoperability, told me on Friday. "We're at a stage where we have a high degree of confidence in it."

Say what? How the hell do you have a 1.0 release of protocol information? So, what, the earlier release was beta? I didn't think of these questions until writing this post, otherwise I would have directly asked Craig last week. Because I wonder: How can somebody develop around protocols that are released but really are incomplete, let alone license them?

Microsoft released preliminary protocol information in April. The 1.0 designation reflects changes incorporated based on community feedback. I wonder how much feedback Microsoft got on licensing terms, which are unchanged.

The protocol information is free to use for non-commercial purposes. But people developing commercial products pay—and if not, their customers do. It's sensible that Microsoft charges for its patented technologies. But European Union sanctions demand free use of server protocol information for open source and free software, a concession Microsoft hasn't made. It's one I expect the company will never make.

"There isn't a cost to learning more," Craig said. "The documentation is posted to MSDN. Anyone can read anytime. Better yet there's a set of forums."

I probed Craig a bit about to see how far Microsoft would pursue non-paying commercial users. Microsoft gives away development tools to college students. What if someone develops an application that goes from free to commercial? I used example of a student charging others for a social networking app using Microsoft protocols. Craig emphasized the difference between a commercial enterprise and a student making "nickels for beer money. I'm not sure that's the most useful way to do the analysis."

Fair enough. Microsoft doesn't want to nickel and dime students out of their nickels and dimes.

Besides protocols for newer products, Microsoft also released information for Office binary file formats, such as .doc and .xls. Enterprises have mountains of valuable data locked away in these older formats. Their interoperability deserves consideration, too, and not just among Microsoft and third-party technologies. The protocols should allow enterprises to better extract meaningful data from older Microsoft file formats.

Microsoft also disclosed patent information. "It is patents that cover those protocols that we're publishing," Craig said. Because of licensing considerations, I asked if information included patents from other companies. "It is Microsoft patents," he affirmed.

Questions remain about Microsoft's interoperability sincerity, whether the company feels forced—by market conditions or European regulators—or has simply changed its ways.

"I would evaluate based on the documentation itself," Craig said. "I would suggest that a serious implentator would roll up his shelves and dive in."

Thoughtfully listening to his responses, I got to thinking about other companies' protocol information publishing. For all the criticism of Microsoft, I can't think of another high-tech company disclosing near as much information. So I asked Craig about other companies publishing protocol information.

"I would love to see others follow our leadership on this," he said.


Tuesday, July 1, 2008

Microsoft.com Goes Virtual

Now this is what corporate blogging is supposed to be about.

Today, Rob Emanuel, a Microsoft technology architect, blogged about Microsoft using Hyper-V technology for Microsoft.com. He earlier blogged—and much more briefly—about using Hyper-V Release Candidate 0 for the MSDN and TechNet sites.

Presumably, Rob's post supports today's Hyper-V release to manufacturing. I didn't see the blog post until this morning (it wasn't there at midnight Pacific time), even though it has a time stamp of 4:38 p.m. PDT yesterday. I assume that Rob simply forgot to update. Too many pesky blogging systems label time when a post is created, forcing the blogger to manually update time and date later on.

I love it when Microsoft employee bloggers describe how the company's dog food is caviar—and that's meant as a compliment, by the way. Microsoft is quick to use its own technology, but it's not as fast telling other people about it. That's changing, and Rob's post is indicative of the trend. The best Microsoft case study is Microsoft.

Rob has put together a nice, concise primer, including Microsoft.com site stats and deployed hardware. Companies like Microsoft don't easily disclose this kind of information. There are competitive and even security considerations, which make the post's existence that much more impressive.

As of today, Microsoft has "25 percent of production traffic" running on Hyper-V, Rob blogged. "Based on these results we are ready to fully host www.microsoft.com web servers on Hyper-V and we're targeting end of June for 50 percent of the load. As soon as we complete deployment of our new hardware infrastructure in diverse data centers, we'll complete the full virtualization."

I don't want to excerpt too much from the post, but these statistics are worth calling out: Microsoft.com "handles 15,000 requests per second, 1.2 billion page views per month, and 280M worldwide unique users per month as well as supporting ~5000 content contributors from within the company," Rob blogged. "This site has close to 300GB of content consisting of some seven million individual files on each server."

Microsoft transparency is best when the company opens up the soul of its own IT operations. No case study is better than Microsoft.

Monday, June 30, 2008

Around the World in Less than 180 Days

When is late early?

This morning, Microsoft announced that its Hyper-V virtualization technology had released to manufacturing. From one perspective, the software shipped late, because it missed the February 27 launch of Windows Server 2008. Looked at another way, the software is early, because the RTM was less than the previously stated "released within 180 days." RTM is more like 120 days, or two months early.

The first rule in any kind of product marketing: Promise one thing and deliver something more. Or as my former JupiterResearch colleague Michael Gartenberg often says, "Under promise and over deliver." I expect there will be many "early" blogs and news stories about Hyper-V today, even though the software is late. Still, Microsoft deserves credit for making up so much development ground so fast. Kudos.

That said, two months early understates just how quickly Microsoft moved out Hyper-V. This morning, I spoke with Mike Neil, general manager of Microsoft Virtualization, about the release timetable. Hyper-V is "available today from Download Center." Microsoft had been indicating August availability just a few months ago.

So it's not August, not third quarter, not second half. Microsoft really released Hyper-V in the first half of the year. That's unusual, given in Microsoft parlance, release almost always means release to manufacturing, with availability some weeks later. "I've been consistent [about] 180 days, and I've always said within," Mike emphasized.

Maybe Microsoft's Server and Tools division had some other pressure—another deadline driving development to reach quality goals early. "It was good to slip this one [in] under the reign of Bill Gates," Mike said. Tomorrow is the Microsoft chairman's last day as a full-time employee.

For those enterprises not wanting to manually download Hyper-V, "on July 8 we will make it available through our Windows Update process," Mike said. The software has already been validated by OEMs for more than 200 systems, he added. Microsoft has expanded the list of supported operating systems, which now includes Windows 2000. See the list.

Windows Server 2008 shipped with the Hyper-V beta, which Mike said most enterprises should be able to easily update manually (through Download Center) or automatically (through Windows Update). The "how easily" should be known shortly, as enterprises begin to deploy the virtualization software.

Hyper-V comes at a time when more enterprises are putting more emphasis on virtualization. According to a recent eWEEK survey of 402 IT decision makers, 32.1 percent of enterprises will have deployed virtual desktop infrastructure by year's end. Meanwhile, 22.3 percent of enterprises will have deployed application virtualization.

Gartner predicts the number of deployed virtual machines will rise from 540,000 at the end of 2006 to more than 4 million in 2009. The major driving force—as in 90 percent of users—is server consolidation.

Many enterprises are consolidating servers in a massive trend not seen in a decade. Sun hugely benefitted from late-1990s server consolidation leading up to the so-called Year 2000 crisis. Mike Neil rightly observed that the TCO concerns drove the last decade's push to consolidate. The reasons are much different today: green computing, as IT organizations seek to reduce energy consumptions and costs related to cooling data centers, regulatory compliance and mobile computing trends, among others.

Pricing is unchanged from earlier announcements. Windows Server 2008 SKUs with Hyper-V cost just $28 more than those without. The price of the additional benefit might not seem much to customers but it could mean more to Microsoft and its partners. Hyper-V inclusion could snatch away potential customers from VMware, among other virtualization developers.

With previous Microsoft virtual server software, businesses had to license two virtualization instances, one for the server partition and another for the applications. Microsoft has modified licensing such that customers pay for only one virtualization instance.

Circling back to this blog's title—headline, if you prefer—and play off the Jules Verne novel, "Around the World in Eighty Days": Server and Tools is rapidly emerging as Microsoft's can-do division. According to a Forrester report published on Friday, "80 percent of firms cite the Redmond software giant as their primary server OS vendor." The division has posted more than 20 consecutive quarters of growth.

At a time when Microsoft's co-founder is stepping aside and CEO Steve Ballmer has sales and marketing executives running the company, it's interesting to see the division with best execution is run by a technical leader—Bob Muglia.

Mike Neil is in the right place, and he knows it—at least for June 26, 2008: "I'm the happiest guy at Microsoft," he said.

Sunday, June 29, 2008

With or Without Yahoo

Online advertising is going to be big, big, big. An IDC forecast indirectly explains why Microsoft didn't let Yahoo go easily.

The analyst firm estimates that Internet advertising spending will reach $65.2 billion this year, and it will increase to $106.6 billion in 2011. Annual estimated growth rate: 15 percent to 20 percent. Impressive, but still small. IDC said that Internet advertising would only account for 10 percent of spending across all media categories this year and 13.6 percent in 2011.

Fortunately for Microsoft, because so much ad money is spent offline, there's still time to get search and online advertising right, with or without Yahoo. Now that could be a U2 song revisited:

See the stone set in your eyes
See the thorn twist in your side
I wait for Yahoo

Sleight of hand and twist of fate
On a bed of nails she makes me wait
And I wait without Yahoo

With or without Yahoo
With or without Yahoo...

And you give yourself away (to Google)
And you give yourself away (to Google)
And you give
And you give
And you give yourself away (to Google)

You get the idea. Microsoft has got to go on either way.

Here's where the "without Yahoo" hurts: Keywords will account for a whopping one-third of online advertising spending through 2011, according to IDC. Combined Microsoft-Yahoo search would have given Microsoft at least a fighting chance against the Google keyword machine.

Something else: IDC said display advertising would account for 20 percent of worldwide ad spending over the next three years. Display advertising is a category where Yahoo actually does well (and Microsoft is doing better).

Microsoft has been throwing out number $80 billion for Internet ad spending by 2010. I stand corrected. I faulted Microsoft's math, but IDC's estimates make that $80 billion just about right.

IDC's forecast is yet another slap in Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer's face. He wanted Yahoo but ended up driving the dot-com pioneer to give itself away to Google—by way of an ad-and-search sharing deal.

I still contend that from an integration perspective, Yahoo would have weighted-down Microsoft to Google's advantage. But reasons for an acquisition look surprisingly stronger now then they did when Microsoft withdrew its acquisition offer:

  • Billionaire Carl Icahn's proxy fight is absolutely undermining the credibility of Yahoo's board (as I said that it would).
  • Important executives are leaping overboard as Yahoo takes on water (I keep thinking of the scene in "Titanic" where steerage passengers follow fleeing rats).
  • Yahoo's executive leadership—once fired up to revive the company—is looking more directionless.
  • In context of the aforementioned problems, Yahoo's stock is finally nearing free-fall.

Microsoft may yet have a chance to pick the search business from Yahoo's rotting bones, although I maintain my opinion that Microsoft's unsolicited takeover hugely contributed to Yahoo's current plight. Before Microsoft's bid—and even a few months afterwards—I saw Yahoo CEO Jerry Yang as steering the company to recovery. I'm no longer confident that he can do it, based on where Yahoo is in the nearly two months since Microsoft withdrew the offer.

Microsoft's alternative, selling search, would have lobotomized Yahoo. But if the body is going to die off anyway—and slowly—maybe a brain transplant would be a good solution. Saving search would preserve something. I must qualify: That's a sensible strategy only if Yahoo can't survive intact. In which case, it's time for Yahoo to fill out that organ donor card, with Microsoft designated as the recipient.

Yahoo's survival and whether or not Google or Microsoft gets some of Jerry Yang's company is an important topic in context of IDC's numbers. While Google, Microsoft and Yahoo are perceived to be competitors, they are not in the greater advertising context. The amount of ad money spent everywhere else, dwarfs Google's online advertising and search dominance.

Google-Microsoft-Yahoo competition is really about jockeying for position to better compete with offline ad spending and to make the biggest bucket for catching those advertising dollars when they finally move online. Right now, Microsoft has a puny bucket compared to Google. According to ComScore, in May, Google's share of worldwide searches was 61.8 percent, compared to 8.5 percent for Microsoft.

Microsoft still has some time, as long as so much ad spending goes offline. It's the bucket's size in three years or even five that will matter more.

Microsoft's 2008 problem: Its bucket wouldn't be as big as Google's, with or without Yahoo.


Saturday, June 28, 2008

Don't Yell 'Yahoo!' So Fast

If Microsoft and Yahoo CEOs accidentally meet in the same trade show bathroom and say "Hello" to one another, have they renewed merger talks?

Need I answer?

Yesterday's renewed Microsoft-Yahoo merger rumor, spurred on in part by TechCrunch's Michael Arrington and debunked today by BoomTown's Kara Swisher, is ridiculous.

I didn't blog the rumor earlier because I didn't believe it, and the major blog reporting the renewed talks has an increasingly bad record for accuracy, recently anyway. TechCrunch is doing a good job of seemingly rushing to be first to blog before checking accuracy. I would be more understanding if there were retractions or corrections.

I suppose Kara could be wrong, except that her reporting on the Microsoft-Yahoo merger has been outstanding and TechCrunch gaffes have me questioning most every post. Anybody recall last month's fake Windows 7 screenshots blasted out to the world as being real? They weren't. There are plenty other examples, but that's the best other Microsoft-related one that comes immediately to mind.

As someone who worked as a lawyer, Michael should know something about negotiating tactics or leaks used as a means of manipulating share prices.

Joe's rules for interpreting negotiation rumors:

1. Nobody talks.
2. Nobody talks.
3. Nobody talks.
4. An associated party only talks when the negotiations aren't going well and one side or the other wants to influence the discussion or end it.
5. Disassociated parties talk when they have another agenda, like influencing stock price of one or both companies.

Nobody talks unless they want something, which makes what they say susceptible. And there is someone here with a really big agenda, billionaire businessman Carl Icahn, who has waged a proxy fight to oust some Yahoo board members, starting with CEO Jerry Yang. Then there are other shareholders disgruntled with Yahoo. Other parties might want to boost Yahoo shares, which recently nipped $20 in their downward spiral. With so many people with possible interest in influencing Yahoo, any unnamed source's reliability should be questioned.

Michael wrote today:

"We've got multiple sources at both Yahoo and Microsoft telling us that official talks are back on between the two companies. But we're hearing something different than CNET—the talks are about a full buyout again, not a sweetened search-only deal."

To his credit, Michael did update the story as new information emerged, but much of it came from other news services. But unnamed sources are the worst kind for a story about the possible merger of two public companies that are hugely influential in their respective market segments.

By the way, at least CNET News.com identified a "major investor who has been in contact with both parties" as a source. But a major investor is a weak source, given the potential conflict of interest here.

Kara wrote yesterday:

"You did not hear it here first, because BoomTown suddenly got the exact same calls too yesterday—coincidence? I think not!—from 'sources' touting Microsoft-Yahoo as 'back on.' I simply could not confirm it to our site's standards of reporting. Which is to say, aiming for trying to report with full accuracy versus repeating errant chatter that is so typical now in this deal."

A Microsoft-Yahoo merger could yet happen. In fact, I detect some desperation on the part of Yahoo. It wouldn't shock me if it was Yahoo banging on Microsoft's door and being rebuffed, in an interesting role reversal. But that's my conjecture. I don't have and wouldn't use unnamed sources about renewed Microsoft-Yahoo talks.


Friday, June 27, 2008

Church Package: Devil in the Details

Whoa, is it the wrath of God or Gates?
Long Zheng blogged about Microsoft's "Holy SKU." It's just too funny, and yet prophetic: Microsoft has got one of the most diversified channels on the planet—and that's a good thing. Strong channel is one of the legacies Microsoft Chairman Bill Gates will leave behind.

"Microsoft Church Package" is a great example of Microsoft's channel at work. Where else could you find a bunch of products from the same company packaged together for the clergy, other than Microsoft's channel or from South Korea? Last time I checked, the world's largest Christian church is in South Korea.

The "Church Package" is loaded up with plenty of productivity apps for drafting and delivering fire-and-brimstone sermons from the pulpit: Expression Web, Office Standard, OneNote, Publisher and Visio. In my experience, ministers do well with just PowerPoint.

I do wonder about the ridiculously low pricing. Do God's people get better pricing than you or me? Well, God certainly might have some advantages negotiating licensing pricing with Microsoft. This entire package sells for 199,000 Won, or about $190 U.S.

Couple years back, my wife took a couple Korean classes at the Korean Embassy in Washington. D.C. I wondered if maybe the pricing was for upgrades—still one hell of a heavenly deal—but she couldn't translate the sales copy.

Microsoft Church Package looks like a short-term promotional, ending June 30. Maybe God and Gates cut a good deal. But $190? Surely, nobody would be so bold as to advertise pirated software, would they? And sold to churches? I'm not suggesting piracy, just asking about it. But, hypothetically, if pirated, watch out! I'd worry more about the wrath of Gates than the wrath of God.

Thursday, June 26, 2008

XP: Microsoft Does the Right Thing

The letter (PDF) from Bill Veghte, senior vice president of the Online Services & Windows Business group, affirms that after June 30 Microsoft will suspend OEM distribution of Windows XP. The extension some people advocated isn't happening. Good. As I've expressed before, Microsoft can't get XP out of the OEM channel fast enough.

But vestiges of XP distribution will continue, since system builders can continue shipping the operating system through Jan. 31, 2009. They acquire the software from distributors. Now this is interesting: "All OEMs, including major OEMs, have this option."

As I previously explained and Bill affirms, businesses have two downgrade rights options, which work similarly with Windows Vista as they did with Windows XP. Volume licensing subscribers can "downgrade" from the Vista preinstalled on their PCs to XP. He also affirms something already announced by Dell and HP:

Some of our OEM partners are planning to offer services designed to help business customers that buy these versions of Windows Vista on new PCs to exercise their downgrade rights. This is a great value because it lets you use Windows XP on new PCs today if you need it and then make the move to take advantage of the additional capabilities of Windows Vista when you are ready, without having to pay for an upgrade.

Some IT managers might define that "great value" as "I don't want stinkin' Vista."

Bill answers the important question that many businesses are asking about XP: Will Microsoft continue support? He writes:

We will continue to provide security updates and other critical updates for Windows XP until April, 2014. Our ongoing support for Windows XP is the result of our recognition that people keep their Windows-based PCs for many years and a reflection of our commitment to provide the highest level of support for all our customers.

There's a saying that confession is good for the spirit. Bill confesses:

The architectural changes that improved security and resilience in Windows Vista led to compatibility issues with existing hardware and applications. Many hardware drivers and applications needed to be updated, and while the majority worked well when we launched Windows Vista, some key applications and drivers were not yet available.

Some businesses still have compatibility problems, which is good reason to use those downgrade rights. But there's hope:

Free downloads like Adobe Reader and iTunes have versions that are optimized for Windows Vista. With the exception of devices that are very old, the vast majority of compatibility and driver issues have been addressed and customers are seeing a much improved user experience.

Bill goes on to espouse Windows Vista Service Pack 1's benefits and say absolutely nothing new about successor Windows 7. It's not like he would give 7's release date, but I could hope.

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner